You can use the default rule to set a default data source for your rendering or hide it if you want. also, try to clear the data source field on rendering control properties:
You can use experience editor rendering web button to test the two conditions you have as you can see in the following screenshot:
Also, you can use explore mode to try testing, I ...
The default state should not have a selected content item. It should be empty. The component will use the data source that was selected when you set-up the component. The UI is a little misleading.
Select your default content when you drop the component on the page. Then set-up your personalization conditions. It should work then.